Verified Document

Should Alcohol Abuse The Categorised As A Disease Essay

¶ … Alcoholism a Disease? There is little doubt that alcoholism is a chronic condition, which in 1956 was classified by the American medical Association as an illness, elevating the status to disease in 1966 (Baldwin Research Institute, 2015). However, despite this announcement, there still appears to be a significant level of dispute within the medical community, where the concept of alcoholism as a disease has remained unproven (Hanson, 2013), however many of the characteristics of the condition appear to be aligned with a disease diagnosis (Borelli, 1989). The aim of this paper is to consider the concept of alcoholism as a disease, considering the evidence for and against this hypothesis.

The Association of alcohol disease began during the 1800s, proposed by Dr. Benjamin Rush, who argues those who drank too much alcohol were diseased, and utilised this argument to promote his revisionist ideas (Baldwin Research Institute, 2015). However, simply calling it a disease does not make it so; indeed a number of commentators have argued that giving alcoholism slave is made more socially acceptable, and created the ability for drinkers to externalise the drunkenness, moving for behavioural decisions from the realm of unsociable social activity, to the sphere of illness (Hill, 1985). This perception has been furthered by the presence of alcoholism, described as alcohol abuse and alcohol...

Each of these propositions will be considered individually.
The first proposition is that heavy drinkers display a singular and distinctive behavioural pattern of ever increasing alcohol use, which leads to increased physical, mental, and psychological deterioration (Hanson, 2013; Fingarette, 1990). Some credibility may be gained by this argument when examining the work of Jellinek (1946), who published a study examining the faces of alcoholism, with research undertaken using self-reporting questionnaires distributed through Alcoholics Anonymous (AA). The research indicated a specific pattern in alcohol abuse, which led to the hypothesis that alcoholism, if untreated, would lead to an inevitable sequence of increased drinking, and the associated symptoms including blackouts, withdrawal distress, and eventually death (Hanson, 2013; Jellinek, 1946). However, while this progression appears to indicate characteristics associated with disease, even Jellinek admitted that the scientific basis for his research, utilising only 100 handpicked…

Sources used in this document:
References

Baldwin Research Institute, (2015), Alcoholism Is Not a Disease, retrieved 12 December 2015 from http://www.baldwinresearch.com/alcoholism.cfm

Borelli, N, (1989), Is Alcoholism Disease, The Journal of the American Medical Association, 262 (1), 343

Fingarette, H, (1990), "Why We Should Reject the Disease Concept of Alcoholism," in Endings, or (Ed), Controversies in the Addictions Field, Dubque, Kendall-Hunt

Hansen, D, (2013), Is Alcoholism a Disease? Retrieved 12 December 2015 from https://archive.is/Vj5lu
National Institute on alcohol abuse and alcoholism (2013), alcohol use disorder: a comparison between DSM IV for DSM 5, retrieved 12 December 2015 from http://pubs.niaaa.nih.gov/publications/dsmfactsheet/dsmfact.pdf
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Fetal Alcohol Syndrome
Words: 3737 Length: 10 Document Type: Case Study

Fetal Alcohol Syndrome Special Education About the Child Pietro is a 7-year-old boy. His biological parents are Argentine and Colombian. He was born approximately six weeks prematurely because of his mother's consumption of alcohol throughout the duration of her pregnancy. According to medical reports, his mother did not consume heavy quantities of alcohol, but she did consume nominal amounts on a regular basis, such as one to three times a week, nearly

Drinking Alcohol Together With Tobacco
Words: 2119 Length: 7 Document Type: Thesis

While each of these studies has reported a cardioprotective effect of alcohol, they differ over which type of alcoholic beverage provides the greatest benefit" (634). Overlooked in many of these studies, though, is the fact that some people who categorize themselves as being one type of drinker compared to another may engage in other activities that are unhealthy from the outset (for instance, beer drinkers may be more likely to

Addiction and the Brain
Words: 2895 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

Psychosocial Ramifications of Drug & Alcohol Abuse A Japanese proverb in its pithiness adequately accounts for the entire process of drug and alcohol abuse. To wit: "Man takes Drink. Drink takes Drink. Drink takes Man." One of the problems with understanding drug or alcohol abuse is the psychosocial ramifications associated with the problem. Moral associations cloud the behavioral and physiological factors. For some time now, alcohol and drug addiction have been

Dually Diagnosed African-American and Latino
Words: 13893 Length: 50 Document Type: Term Paper

(1999) which are: 1) Those with serious mental illnesses such as schizophrenia, bi-polar disorder with major depression and who use alcohol and drugs to self-mediate to cope with the symptoms; and 2) Those with borderline personality and anti-social personality disorders including anxiety disorder that is complicated by use of alcohol and illicit drugs. (Mather et al. 1999) Presenting further difficulty is the establishment of problems with alcohol and illicit drug use

Reality TV Reinforce Negative Role
Words: 5002 Length: 17 Document Type: Term Paper

However, the ability to criticize and gain depth into a subject was the key factors involved in qualitative research. In order for qualitative research methods to be applied to qualitative research, these methods had to undergo some form of transformation to make them acceptable to the empirical mindset. Wainwright argues that in order to achieve this, qualitative methods had to sacrifice some of their critical elements in favor of

Nursing Community Assessment
Words: 2602 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

Nursing Community Assessment It is moral responsibility of the Government and the nursing organizations to maintain the health standard in any country. However, it is not wholly in the hands of these organizations but other departments must also contribute for this cause. This study is focused on the county of Astoria, Queens, New York for helping the nurses in doing their job in the right way. The study highlights the demographics, major

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now